Best in #SWEDOW 2010: Announcing the Winners!

19 Jan

The Best In #SWEDOW 2010:

Woo-hoo! Maybe you thought I’d forgotten or decided to let it slide. But no. Here are the 2010 winners of what may very likely become an annual event here at Tales From the Hood: The Best in #SWEDOW:

Underneath your clothes: Steve takes home the gold in this category with his winning entry: Knickers 4 Africa. This cutting-edge charity from the land that gave us Led Zeppelin and Oxfam will deliver your gently used knickers (er… “panties” for American readers) – no thongs, please – to a knicker-less woman in the country of “Africa.”

It’s All About the Children: Maureen takes the gold in this category with a #SWEDOW classic: Little Dresses for Africa. Got some used pillow cases? Wash the drool out and then turn those bad boys into – you guessed it – little dresses for Africa.

(Very honorable mention in this category goes to “d” who makes a strong showing with Teddies For Tragedies, Puppets for Orphans, and another #SWEDOW classic: Global Soap. Go “d”!)

#AidFootFetish. I must say that I was suprised and a tiny bit disappointed in the overall lack of competition in this category. Nonetheless, I am very pleased to award the gold to “AD” for the ever controversial Soles 4 Souls. You know, ’cause they’re totally running out of made-in-China flip-flops… er.. somewhere.

Out of Africa: Martin cleans house in this category by drawing our attention to an attempted fiasco involving 100,000 servings of organic baby food for Pakistan. Despite a great deal of irate-ness in – uh – New Zealand (few things are more dangerous than a bunch of riled up Kiwis), both UNICEF and the Red Cross had the good sense to leave this one at the table.

GRAND PRIZE: And the winner of the 2010 Best in #SWEDOW is…

AD for The Breast Milk Project. I think this is the first time I’m hearing of biological #SWEDOW. Might have to add that as a category next year

As previously announced, all prizes will be provided from @meowtree’s personal #SWEDOW collection. Winners, please post your post/mailing details in the comments thread or send to me at talesfromethehood(at)gmail(dot)com.

Thank you to everyone who entered. Hope to see you all again next year!

About these ads

18 Responses to “Best in #SWEDOW 2010: Announcing the Winners!”

  1. Anonymous 19 January, 2011 at 1:20 pm #

    Could someone more knowledgeable that me post details on why each of these organizations is ineffective/harmful? Thanks.

  2. AD 19 January, 2011 at 9:38 pm #

    Wow, thank you so much J. and the other judges! What a wonderful honor to have nominated the best (ahem, worst)#SWEDOW organization in 2010. Many thanks also for the Foot Fetish Award. I never imagined that The Breast Milk Project would move #SWEDOW into new territory, but look forward to the biological category in years to come.

  3. Sam Gardner 20 January, 2011 at 3:42 pm #

    Aren’t we just little bit too smug? Why not including a category of honestly good things to send? I know of a program just financing SWEDOW projects, but at least 10 % of the projects send cost-effective, useful things.

    • J. 21 January, 2011 at 4:28 pm #

      My math’s terrible, but I think you just asked me to honorably mention an org/project that is 90% *not* cost-effective, *not* useful…

      • Sam Gardner 23 January, 2011 at 2:48 am #

        No, I would like you to acknowledge that there is Stuff We Don’t Want, that can be put to very good use in a cost-effective and efficient way in the 3rd world. By creating a negative political correctness on swedow, you will be stopping also the one project in 1000 where this is the best answer.

        I agree that 99 % of the swedow is also stedow (stuff they don’t want). But to allow for effectiveness, you should also allow for the 1 % to happen. Creating a “kill them all” environment wont work. It is the same strategy that caused the problem in the first place: political correctness based on conventional wisdom. It keeps the cycle of fads in motion.

        I see this will not work without an example. Old dentist chairs are swedow. However, in some areas in the third world they can be a godsend: the new ones are just not affordable (notice all the “some”and “can”). Of course, if the market would be perfect, the market would organize the transport more effectively than whatever project can do.

        Once again, I agree that Sedow must stop being business as usual asap, and support your campaign. I only argue for some modesty.

  4. Matt Richmond 24 January, 2011 at 12:51 pm #

    It would be better to kill the 10% in order to get rid of the 90% than it would be to keep the 90% for the 10%. Frankly.

  5. Alex Orenstein 3 February, 2011 at 2:07 am #

    I know it’s a bit late but I wish I had discovered this piece of SWEDOW earlier….it might be the worst EVER.

    Enjoy

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. A good example of Development? « EWB placement Nepal - 21 January, 2011

    [...] and one anonymous development aid blogger runs a yearly competition to find the worst cases of “SWEDOW” or Stuff (I prefer Shit) We Don’t Want. Knickers for Africa? Teddies for tragedy? Really? [...]

  2. Rwanda bans used underwear imports | Good Intentions Are Not Enough - 25 January, 2011

    [...] The best in #SWEDOW 2010 – Tales from the Hood [...]

  3. Fat of the Land. Ultimate SWEDOW « Arrested Development - 3 February, 2011

    [...] though Tales From The Hood has covered SWEDOW (Shit We Don’t Want) impeccably, we have perhaps found the worst case of [...]

  4. Dear Jas- er- I mean- World Vision « WanderLust - 8 February, 2011

    [...] people in underpriveleged communities, and are not driven by corporations and industries who give SWEDOW to get tax-breaks (we should have a seperate conversation about food-aid at some point as [...]

  5. When is it a bad idea to give the poor free stuff? « BUEC - 2 March, 2011

    [...] very-funny SWEDOW (Stuff We Don’t Want) Awards make this pretty clear.  This year’s winners included a British charity called Knickers4Africa which, if you don’t speak British like I [...]

  6. Weekly round-up – Private Actors | development6057 - 7 March, 2011

    [...] GIK (Gifts In Kind) – is probably not going away soon. And of course there are the SWEDOW awards (also here and here, I’ll let you figure out what that means). On the bright side, there are [...]

  7. >When is it a bad idea to give the poor free stuff? « Graph Backwards - 31 May, 2011

    [...] very-funny SWEDOW (Stuff We Don’t Want) Awards make this pretty clear.  This year’s winners included a British charity called Knickers4Africa which, if you don’t speak British like I [...]

  8. Chupa: A constructive case of SWEDOW « A Year in Kigali, Rwanda - 14 July, 2011

    [...] Talk about one man’s trash being another man’s treasure. Seeing children so excited about receiving what people driving by toss away as unwanted garbage reminded me of a blog post I read a few months ago by a blogger who works in the humanitarian aid industry. The anonymous blogger coined the term SWEDOW, or “stuff we don’t want” to describe his/her criticism of well intentioned but ill conceived and ultimately useless, self-serving, and occasionally harmful in-kind donations to Africa from developed countries. Some examples include used shoes and clothing, pillowcases, anti-ageing skin cream, and even breast milk. [...]

  9. Haiti Doesn’t Need Your Old T-Shirt | American Think Tank - 11 October, 2011

    [...] for African children. The blog Tales from the Hood, run by an anonymous aid worker, even set up a SWEDOW prize, won by Knickers 4 Africa, a (thankfully now defunct) British NGO set up a couple of years ago to [...]

  10. #SWEDOW2012 « AidSpeak - 19 November, 2012

    [...] “The Best in #SWEDOW 2012″ – the winners of the most recent #SWEDOW competition. [...]

  11. Garbage bags full of burgers (or, Why it’s important to actually talk to aid recipients) « Uphill - 5 December, 2012

    [...] other words, the Red Cross is being accused of giving away inappropriate goods and in a way that’s not helpful, not coordinating properly with local people and [...]

Pearls of wisdom

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 672 other followers

%d bloggers like this: